BEST BOOKS WITH PLOT TWISTS YOU WON’T EXPECT

Best Books With Plot Twists You Won’t Expect

Best Books With Plot Twists You Won’t Expect

Blog Article

Best Books With Plot Twists You Won’t Expect


Look, we’ve all been there—you’re halfway through a book, starting to feel pretty clever because you think you know exactly where the story’s going. Then bam. That twist hits, and suddenly you’re staring at the page like it just slapped you. The best plot twist books don’t just surprise you. They make you re-evaluate everything you thought you understood. And if you're a fan of that kind of literary whiplash? You're in for a ride.

Here are my personal picks for the best books with plot twists you won’t expect. These are the ones that had me gasping, flipping back pages, and immediately texting friends with some version of "YOU NEED TO READ THIS."

1. Behind Her Eyes by Sarah Pinborough


This book is the literal definition of "you won't see it coming." What starts as a domestic thriller with a slightly weird love triangle ends in absolute chaos—the good kind. It plays with dreams, memory, and psychological tension in a way that feels like a Netflix series in book form. (Oh wait, it is a Netflix series now.)

Why it works: It layers supernatural elements under everyday drama, so when the twist lands, it doesn’t feel cheap—just earned and bonkers.
Search tip: People often find this by Googling "books like Verity with a twist ending." Add it to your list.


2. The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides


I know, I know—everyone and their mom has read this one. But there's a reason for that. A famous painter shoots her husband five times in the face and never speaks again. The mystery isn't the murder—it's the silence. And when that silence breaks?

Yeah. That moment still haunts me.

Perfect for: Fans of psychological thrillers who love an unreliable narrator and a big finale that makes you rethink the whole book.

You can find it here on Everand if you're ready to have your mind thoroughly messed with.

3. Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn


Yes, this one’s iconic, but it has to be on this list. Gone Girl practically defined the modern twist-driven thriller. It weaponizes perspective like no other book I’ve read. You think you're reading about a missing wife and a shady husband, but what you're actually reading is a masterclass in manipulation.

Long-tail search gold: "best thrillers with dual POV" or "books where the twist changes everything"
Bonus: Flynn’s Sharp Objects is another twisted gem worth checking out. But this one? Chef's kiss.


4. We Were Liars by E. Lockhart


Here’s a YA title that totally wrecked me. It follows a wealthy family, an idyllic summer, and a narrator you desperately want to believe. It's lyrical and slow-building, and then—the twist. It’s brutal. You’ll either love it or throw the book across the room. Maybe both.

Best for: Readers who enjoy emotional storytelling with a darker, haunting payoff.

It's constantly trending in the BookTok "books that broke me" niche, by the way.

5. Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane


If you’ve only seen the movie, I promise you the book is just as chilling—if not more. The psychological layers in Shutter Island mess with your sense of reality in a way that lingers. Teddy Daniels is investigating a disappearance at a psychiatric facility... but let’s just say he might be closer to the truth than he thinks.

Fun fact: The twist here is so well-executed, it’s used in creative writing courses as an example of how to do unreliable narration right.

6. The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton


This book is... a lot. But in the best way. It’s like Agatha Christie meets Inception meets Groundhog Day. Every time the protagonist wakes up, he’s in a new body, trying to solve a murder. It’s dense, but it rewards your attention tenfold.

Who it’s for: Puzzle-solvers. If you love annotating and tracking clues, this book will be your jam.

Search trends show it ranking under "mystery books with time loops" or "books like Knives Out with a twist."

7. Before I Go to Sleep by S.J. Watson


This one’s been out for a while, but it still holds up. A woman wakes up every day with no memory of who she is. Each morning, her husband explains everything—but not all of it adds up. You’ll spend the whole book unsure of who to trust.

Keyword gold: "memory loss thrillers" or "books like The Girl on the Train"

Also: the audiobook is incredible if you like immersive narration that plays with perception.

Quick Picks With Killer Twists


Sometimes, you just want to skip the preamble and get to the goods. So here are a few more titles that earn their place on this list:

  • Lock Every Door by Riley Sager

  • The Girl With a Clock for a Heart by Peter Swanson

  • Verity by Colleen Hoover (love it or hate it, that twist is something)

  • I’m Thinking of Ending Things by Iain Reid (caution: it’s... deeply weird)

  • The Last Mrs. Parrish by Liv Constantine



What Makes a Twist Actually Work?


You can’t just toss a random shock into a story and call it a plot twist. The best ones are earned.

  • They reframe the entire narrative

  • They come out of nowhere but still make sense

  • They make you want to re-read the book from page one


And you know what? They stick with you. Long after the story ends, you're still thinking about that moment.

Final Thoughts: Go In Blind (Mostly)


If you really want to experience these books the way they were meant to be read, avoid spoilers like the plague. Don’t read the Goodreads comments. Don’t peek at too many reviews. Just trust me: grab one of these titles, hit play (or flip that first page), and let the book do what it came to do.

Happy reading—and hey, if one of these messes you up emotionally? You’re welcome.

P.S. Got a favorite plot twist book I missed? Shoot me a DM or drop it in the comments. I’m always looking for my next obsession.

Report this page